Review · KEY WEST
Marathon Florida Keys Fishing Experience
The best part of this Marathon fishing charter is its flexibility. Captain Ed and first mate Mikey take you into the coastal waters around the Florida Keys, choosing between the Atlantic Ocean and Gulf of Mexico based on the trip you book and where the fish are biting. You might target snappers, groupers, mackerel, yellow jacks, or even an occasional shark.
I like the family-friendly setup, since children and first-time anglers can take part without bringing equipment or buying a fishing license. I also like the practical finish: your catch can be cleaned, and the crew can point you toward a local restaurant for a hook-and-cook meal.
The main consideration is the trip length. Four hours gives you a taste of Keys fishing, but serious anglers may want six hours or the separate eight-hour offshore option. Also confirm the group limit when booking, since the advertised price allows up to six people while the additional information lists a maximum of four.
Key points to know before booking

- Captain Ed and Mikey lead the trip: You get a captain and first mate who work together and focus on finding fish rather than simply watching the clock.
- Near-shore fishing offers variety: Snappers, groupers, mackerel, yellow jacks, and other species are possible, with an occasional shark in the mix.
- The catch can become dinner: Fish cleaning is included, and the crew can recommend a local restaurant for a hook-and-cook meal.
- The four-hour trip suits families: You get a manageable outing with equipment, bait, tackle, licenses, and water supplied.
- The eight-hour trip changes the goal: Offshore fishing is available for mahi mahi, tuna, sailfish, wahoo, and other big-game species.
- Weather can affect the plan: Poor conditions may lead to a new date or a full refund, while cancellations made less than 24 hours ahead are not refunded.
What fishing around Marathon actually involves

This is not a sightseeing cruise with a fishing rod added as an afterthought. The purpose is to spend your time working the waters around Marathon, where the Atlantic side and Gulf side offer different fishing conditions and species.
On the four-hour or six-hour coastal charter, the crew may take you near shore in either body of water. The exact route depends on the option you choose, local conditions, and where Captain Ed believes the fish are holding. That flexibility matters in the Keys, where wind and currents can change the day’s plan.
You should expect a hands-on outing rather than a fixed list of stops. There is no promised catch or single signature species. Instead, the appeal is variety: snappers, groupers, mackerel, yellow jacks, and other fish may all be part of the day. An occasional shark is also possible.
That mix works well for families and mixed groups. One person may want a fish for dinner, another may simply want the excitement of a strong bite, and a more experienced angler may enjoy seeing what turns up. The tradeoff is that you should not book the four-hour coastal trip expecting a dedicated trophy-fish expedition.
More fishing trips around Key West:
- Key West Half-Day Fishing Charter
★ 4.5 · 408 reviews - Key West 6-Hour Party Boat Fishing Trip – Affordable Reef Fishing
★ 4.5 · 325 reviews - Key West Deep Sea Fishing: Big Fish
★ 5.0 · 112 reviews
How the four-hour charter fits into a Florida Keys day
Four hours is a sensible length if you are fitting fishing between other Marathon plans. You get enough time to reach productive water, fish, and return without giving up most of the day.
For children, teenagers, and people who are new to fishing, the shorter trip may be the better choice. It keeps the outing focused and avoids making the day feel like a test of endurance. The reports of children aged 11 and 14 having a good time support this as a practical family option.
A four-hour trip also makes financial sense for a group that wants to try fishing without committing to a full-day charter. At $895 per group, the price is not low for a short outing, but it is shared across the group rather than charged per person. If four people go, that works out to about $224 per person. With six people, it drops to about $149 per person, assuming the larger group is accepted.
There is an important detail here: the booking information gives a price for up to six people, but another section lists a maximum of four. I would settle that point directly before paying, especially if you are planning for five or six people.
When six hours makes more sense

The six-hour option gives the crew more time to adjust when wind, current, or the first fishing spot is not producing. That extra time can matter on a day when the conditions are challenging.
Captain Ed has been praised for finding fish despite changing winds and currents. That is useful context because fishing is not a machine. A captain cannot order fish to appear, but a flexible route and extra time can improve your chances of finding active water.
I would choose six hours for an adult group that cares more about fishing than fitting in several other activities. It also makes sense if you are hoping to build a larger catch or try more than one type of fishing. Still, the available information does not promise a set number of fish, a particular fishing method, or a guaranteed species.
The crew’s approach seems relaxed rather than rigid. You are not simply being rushed back to the dock when the scheduled time approaches. That can be valuable, though you should still treat the listed duration as an approximate four or six hours rather than assuming the boat will run far beyond the planned trip.
The possible catch, from yellow jacks to shark

The near-shore charter is built around variety. Snappers and groupers are familiar Florida Keys targets, while mackerel can add speed and excitement. Yellow jacks have also been a productive catch on this trip, and they can provide a good dinner when cleaned properly.
The crew cleans the fish you keep. That is a small but important service. It means you do not have to figure out the messy work after returning to shore, and it makes a hook-and-cook dinner much easier to arrange.
Captain Ed and Mikey can also recommend a local restaurant that prepares fresh catch. Ask about this before you leave the boat if turning the day’s fishing into dinner is part of your plan. The restaurant recommendation is not presented as an included meal, so you should expect to pay the restaurant separately.
You may also encounter other species, including an occasional shark. That possibility adds a little excitement, but it should not be treated as a promise of a shark encounter. The best mindset is to enjoy the range of fish available rather than measure the trip against one specific catch.
Same water, another way to fish it:
- KeyWest Half-Day Inshore Fishing Private Charter
★ 5.0 · 64 reviews - Fishing Charters in Key West Florida
★ 4.5 · 46 reviews - Private Fishing Charter from Ramrod Key
★ 5.0 · 45 reviews - Key West: Private Fishing Charter with Experienced Captain
★ 5.0 · 16 reviews
What Captain Ed and Mikey add to the outing

The crew is a major part of the experience. Captain Ed handles the trip, while Mikey serves as first mate, and they are described as a father-and-son team. Their roles give the outing a personal feel without taking away from the practical work of baiting, handling equipment, and helping the group.
That matters most when your party includes children or people who do not fish often. Patience and clear help can make the difference between a child feeling lost and feeling involved. The crew has been praised for being patient with a family that included two children, and for keeping the mood friendly and professional.
The crew also seems willing to adapt to the group. One account describes more than 30 fish across more than seven varieties, with the crew staying focused on the group’s enjoyment rather than rushing through the trip. Catch totals vary, of course. A good day for one group is not a guarantee for the next.
I would also value the straightforward style attributed to Captain Ed and Mikey. Fishing charters work best when the captain gives you a realistic picture of the conditions and does not pretend every trip will produce a record catch.
What the $895 group price includes

The $895 price covers the charter for the group, not an individual seat. The stated inclusions are bottled water, all fishing equipment, bait, tackle, and fishing licenses.
That is a useful bundle. You do not need to buy a rod, bring bait, or arrange a license before boarding. For a first-time angler, those details remove much of the planning work. For an experienced angler, it means you can travel light.
The value depends heavily on group size. Two people would pay the equivalent of $447.50 each, before any separate meal costs. Four people would pay about $223.75 each. If six are accepted, the per-person cost becomes much more attractive at roughly $149.17 each.
Because the information conflicts on the maximum group size, confirm whether your party can include more than four people. I would also ask which trip length the $895 price applies to, since the experience offers four-hour and six-hour coastal options and an eight-hour offshore charter. The supplied price is clearly listed for the experience, but it does not spell out every price difference between those choices.
The eight-hour offshore option for serious anglers

The eight-hour trip is a different proposition from the shorter coastal outings. It is aimed at offshore big-game fishing for mahi mahi, tuna, sailfish, wahoo, and other species.
If your main goal is a large offshore fish, this is the option to ask about. It gives the crew a full day to work farther from shore and pursue species that are not the central focus of the four-hour coastal trip.
The longer outing will require more commitment from your group. It takes up most of a day, so it is less convenient for a family trying to fit in several Marathon activities. On the other hand, anglers who are disappointed by a brief near-shore trip may find the eight-hour plan more satisfying.
Do not assume the offshore charter is automatically included in the $895 price. The information identifies it as an available option but does not give a separate rate or exact details. Confirm the price, group limit, departure time, and target species before booking that version.
Meeting in Marathon and planning your day

The meeting point is at 11833 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, Florida 33050. The activity ends back at that same location, so you can plan around a clear departure and return point rather than arranging a separate pickup.
The experience is associated with Key West in the broad destination information, but the actual meeting point is in Marathon. That distinction matters. Marathon is in the Middle Keys, not Key West, so check your accommodation and driving plan carefully.
The location is near public transportation, though no specific route or service is provided. I would not rely on that phrase alone if your party has fishing gear, children, or a tight schedule. Confirm how you will reach the meeting point and allow time to arrive before departure.
The experience is offered in English. Confirmation is provided at booking, and the ticket is mobile, which keeps the arrival process simple as long as your phone is charged and the confirmation is easy to access.
Weather, cancellations, and the practical fine print
Fishing depends on the weather, and this charter requires good conditions. If poor weather forces a cancellation, you are offered another date or a full refund. That policy gives you some protection when conditions are unsafe or unsuitable.
You can cancel for a full refund up to 24 hours before the local start time. A cancellation made less than 24 hours before departure is not refunded, and changes inside that window are not accepted.
I would avoid scheduling this as the one fixed activity that cannot move. Leave some space in your Florida Keys plans, especially during unsettled weather. The weather rule protects the safety of the trip, but it can still disrupt a tightly packed holiday schedule.
Who should book this Marathon charter
I would recommend this trip to families, couples, and small groups who want a private fishing outing without supplying their own gear. It is especially suitable if your group includes beginners, children, or people who would rather catch several kinds of fish than focus on one difficult target.
The four-hour option is the best fit for a first attempt or a busy holiday. The six-hour outing suits anglers who want more time to adjust to conditions and pursue a fuller day on the water. The eight-hour offshore choice belongs to people who specifically want big-game possibilities.
I would hesitate if your group is only one or two people and the cost feels high. The price becomes easier to justify when shared among four people or more. I would also hesitate if your schedule cannot handle a weather change, or if your main goal is a guaranteed shark, tuna, sailfish, or other single species.
Should you book Wet Tails Charters?
Book it if you want a practical, family-friendly fishing day with Captain Ed and Mikey, especially if a cleaned catch and a local hook-and-cook dinner appeal to you. The included equipment, bait, tackle, licenses, and water reduce the fuss, while the range of possible species keeps the outing interesting.
Before you commit, confirm three points: the exact trip length, the price for your chosen option, and whether your group limit is four or six. If those details work for your party, the four-hour coastal charter offers a sensible introduction to Marathon fishing, while the longer trips give dedicated anglers more time and bigger ambitions.
FAQ
Where does the fishing charter meet?
The meeting point is 11833 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL 33050, USA. The activity returns to that same location.
How long is the fishing trip?
The coastal charter is available for four or six hours. An eight-hour offshore big-game charter is also offered.
How much does the experience cost?
The listed price is $895 per group, with the price information stating up to six people. Another part of the information lists a maximum of four, so confirm the allowed group size before booking.
What is included in the price?
Bottled water, all fishing equipment, bait, tackle, and fishing licenses are included.
What fish might I catch?
The coastal trip may target snappers, groupers, mackerel, yellow jacks, and other species. An occasional shark is also possible. The offshore trip is offered for mahi mahi, tuna, sailfish, wahoo, and other big-game species.
Is the charter suitable for children?
The information says most people can participate, and the experience is described as suitable for the entire family. A family with children aged 11 and 14 had a successful outing.
Is the experience offered in English?
Yes. The charter is offered in English.
Can I cancel for a full refund?
Yes, if you cancel at least 24 hours before the experience start time. Cancellations made less than 24 hours ahead are not refunded.
What happens if bad weather cancels the trip?
If poor weather causes the experience to be canceled, you are offered a different date or a full refund.
Just landed around Key West
- Private Fishing Charter Florida Keys★ 5.0 · 6 reviews
- 4 hours Private Fishing Charters in Key West 40 Ft Irish Cowboy★ 5.0 · 9 reviews
- Deep Sea Fishing-Key West Since 1965-45 FT Cowgirl-Cold AC-4 Hrs★ 4.5 · 11 reviews
- Key West Private Fishing Charters- 4 HRS 36 FT HATTERAS COWBOY★ 5.0 · 5 reviews
- Marathon Offshore Fishing Charter★ 3.0 · 2 reviews
- Marathon Reef Fishing Charters★ 5.0 · 7 reviews
- Key West Night Fishing Head Boat Fishing Trip★ 3.5 · 2 reviews
- Key West Sandbar Fishing Snorkel Catch and Cook Excursions★ 5.0 · 9 reviews
Key West Fishing Trips, compared.

Key West 6-Hour Party Boat Fishing Trip – Affordable Reef Fishing
Read our review →
KeyWest Half-Day Inshore Fishing Private Charter
Read our review →
Key West: Private Fishing Charter with Experienced Captain
Read our review →Other lists this trip sits in





