Review · KEY WEST
Key West: Private Fishing Charter with Experienced Captain
The best part of this Key West charter is the freedom to fish as your own group, not beside strangers. Captain Craig and first mates Brett and Riley take up to six people aboard the Double Wrap, then adjust the plan to the season, sea conditions, and the fish that are biting.
I like the private boat setup, which works well for families and small groups with mixed skill levels. I also like that the crew supplies the gear, bait, lures, and fishing license, then cleans and filets the fish you choose to keep. The main thing to consider is that a four-hour trip gives you less time offshore than the six-hour or eight-hour choices, and rough seas can make the ride lively.
Key points
- Private group of up to six: You get the boat to yourselves, with no other parties joining.
- Captain Craig and mates Brett and Riley: The crew can help first-timers while keeping experienced anglers busy.
- Several fishing styles: Trolling, bottom fishing, live baiting, wreck fishing, and deep dropping may all be used.
- Offshore range of 6 to 16 miles: Your distance from shore depends on trip length and the bite.
- Fishing gear and license included: Bring only personal items, snacks, drinks, sunscreen, and hats.
- Fish cleaning included: The crew will clean and filet the catch you want to take home.
Leaving The Perry Hotel for Offshore Key West

The trip begins at The Perry Hotel & Marina, at 7001 Shrimp Road on Stock Island. That location is useful if you are staying near Key West but do not want to spend time reaching a marina farther along the Keys. One person who took the half-day option especially liked being close to downtown Key West, rather than driving out to another island.
From the marina, you head offshore with your private party. The charter may travel roughly 6 to 16 miles from land, depending on the length of your trip and where the fish are active. That range matters. A short outing may focus on nearby waters and a quick return, while a longer charter gives the crew more time to reach productive grounds and change tactics.
You should treat the departure time as the start of the fishing window, not the moment you begin planning. Have your group ready with hats, sunscreen, drinks, and snacks before you arrive. A cooler is available for your food and beverages, and keeping personal items simple will make the boat easier to move around on.
More Fishing Charters in the USA
- Key West Half-Day Fishing Charter
★ 4.5 · 408 reviews - KeyWest Half-Day Inshore Fishing Private Charter
★ 5.0 · 64 reviews - Fishing Charters in Key West Florida
★ 4.5 · 46 reviews
Choosing Four, Six, or Eight Hours on the Water
The four-hour charter is the practical choice if you want a taste of offshore fishing without giving up most of the day. It can work well for families, first-time anglers, or anyone fitting fishing around other Key West plans. The tradeoff is clear: travel time, setup, changing spots, and the return trip all use part of those four hours.
A six-hour trip gives you more room to try different methods. If the crew starts with trolling and then moves to bottom fishing or live bait, the extra time makes those changes more worthwhile. You also have a better chance of reaching farther offshore without making the trip feel rushed.
The eight-hour option suits serious anglers and groups that want the greatest flexibility. More time can mean more areas, more techniques, and a better chance to wait out a slow spell. Fishing is never guaranteed, though. A longer trip improves your opportunity, not the certainty of a catch.
I would choose four hours for a first fishing outing or a group with young participants. I would look at six hours for a mixed group that wants a proper fishing day. Eight hours makes the most sense when everyone in your party genuinely wants to spend most of the day on the water.
Fishing for Mahi Mahi, Snapper, and Sailfish
The species depend on the season and conditions. Possible targets include mahi mahi, snapper, grouper, king mackerel, wahoo, tuna, sailfish, and other fish found offshore around Key West. That variety gives the captain options when one method is not producing.
Mahi mahi can provide fast action and are a popular target for a mixed group. Snapper and grouper offer a different style of fishing, often requiring you to work closer to the bottom. King mackerel, wahoo, tuna, and sailfish bring the possibility of faster, stronger fish, but they are not something the crew can promise on a particular morning.
The range of methods is one of the strongest parts of the charter. Trolling lets you cover water while looking for active fish. Bottom fishing focuses your effort in productive deeper areas. Live baiting can appeal to anglers who like a more direct presentation, while wreck fishing and deep dropping offer other ways to target fish below the surface.
The captain may shift methods during the trip instead of locking you into one plan. That is important because fishing conditions change. You are not simply handed a rod and left to figure it out. The crew provides the equipment and helps with the work needed to fish.
What Captain Craig and the Crew Add
Captain Craig has more than 15 years of commercial fishing experience. That background matters most in the practical decisions: where to go, when to change methods, and how to respond when the bite slows or the sea gets rough.
First mates Brett and Riley have also received especially strong praise for helping with the fishing and looking after the group. Brett is specifically mentioned by name alongside Captain Craig after a day that produced snapper and mahi mahi. On another trip, Captain Craig and both mates kept working from departure until the boat returned.
I like the crew’s apparent balance of help and low-key service. The boat is set up for people who already fish often, but the crew can also accommodate a first-time angler. That makes this a better pick for a family or group of friends with different comfort levels than a specialized trip aimed only at experts.
You should still tell the crew what kind of day you want. If your group wants food fish, say so. If you care more about trying for a large offshore species, say that too. The captain is happy to tailor the trip, within the limits of the weather, season, and available fish.
More Private Fishing Charters in the USA
- Private Fishing Charter from Ramrod Key
★ 5.0 · 45 reviews - 4 hours Private Fishing Charters in Key West 40 Ft Irish Cowboy
★ 5.0 · 9 reviews - Key West: Private Inshore Fishing Charter
★ 5.0 · 7 reviews - Private Fishing Charter Florida Keys
★ 5.0 · 6 reviews
The Double Wrap and the Private-Boat Advantage
The charter uses the Double Wrap, described as a nice boat with room for up to six passengers. Since the entire boat is private to your party, you can set the tone for the outing. A serious angler can focus on fishing, while a less experienced person can ask questions without feeling out of place.
That privacy also makes the price easier to understand. The listed cost is $900 per group, not per person, for up to six people. With six passengers, that works out to $150 each. With four people, the effective cost is $225 per person, and with only two, it becomes $450 each.
So this is strongest value for a full group of five or six. A smaller party may still prefer the privacy and personal attention, but should compare the group cost with other Key West activities before booking. The boat’s private format is the main reason to pay a group rate rather than looking for a shared fishing excursion.
The mobile ticket keeps the booking simple. Confirmation arrives at booking, and the charter returns to the same marina where it begins.
What to Bring and What Is Already Covered
You do not need to arrange a fishing license or rent basic gear separately. The charter provides the necessary fishing equipment, lures, bait, and license. That removes several small costs and avoids the need to pack a tackle box for a trip you may never repeat.
Bring sunscreen and a hat, along with snacks and drinks. The cooler is available for storage. I would also wear clothing that can handle spray and fish handling, though the supplied information does not specify a dress code.
The crew will clean and filet the fish you decide to keep. That is a useful service at the end of a long day. You can finish the trip with the catch prepared rather than returning to shore with an unhandled fish and another chore waiting.
Fish cleaning does not mean you are guaranteed to bring home dinner. The available species depend on the season, the bite, the weather, and the rules that apply to the catch. The practical benefit is that, if you do keep fish, the crew helps with the messy part.
How Rough Water Can Change the Day
One fishing trip produced mahi mahi, king mackerel, and a 75-inch sailfish even though the seas were choppy. That gives you a useful picture of the outing: a rough ride does not automatically cancel the fishing, but it can affect comfort.
If you are prone to motion sickness, consider how much time you want offshore before choosing eight hours. The four-hour option limits your exposure if the sea is unsettled. On the other hand, a longer trip gives the crew more time to work around changing conditions when it is safe to do so.
The charter requires good weather. If poor weather forces cancellation, you can choose another date or receive a full refund. That policy protects you from losing the entire $900 when conditions make the trip unsafe or impractical.
You should also keep the schedule flexible around the sea. Changes made less than 24 hours before departure are not accepted, and cancellations made at least 24 hours ahead receive a full refund. Cutoff times follow local Key West time.
Who Will Get the Most From This Charter
I would recommend this trip to a group of friends, a family, or a small fishing party that wants the boat to itself. The private format is especially helpful when some people are experienced anglers and others need instruction.
It also suits people who want several possible targets rather than one fixed species. The crew may use trolling, live baiting, bottom fishing, wreck fishing, or deep dropping, depending on what makes sense that day.
First-time anglers should feel comfortable asking for help. The captain and mate are there to assist, and the supplied gear removes much of the preparation. More experienced anglers may appreciate the chance to discuss targets and techniques with a captain who has spent more than 15 years in commercial fishing.
I would think twice if only one or two people in your party want to fish. The $900 group price is much easier to justify when divided among six passengers. I would also reconsider a full eight-hour trip if your group is unsure about seasickness or only wants a brief introduction to offshore fishing.
Booking Ahead and Keeping Expectations Real
This charter is booked about 48 days ahead on average. That suggests you should reserve early if your Key West dates are fixed, especially if you need a particular day or want the longer option.
Keep your expectations focused on the experience, not a guaranteed haul. The crew can work hard, change techniques, and put you in places where fish may be active, but no captain controls the season, weather, or bite. The strongest promise here is a serious effort, not a certain number of fish.
The fishing can be productive. A short trip produced five good fish for one group, and another outing brought in plenty of snapper and mahi mahi. A different trip earned the unusual thrill of a 75-inch sailfish. Those results show what is possible, but they should not be read as a daily forecast.
Should You Book the Double Wrap Charter?
Book it if you can fill most of the six seats and want a private Key West fishing day with gear, bait, licenses, and fish cleaning included. Captain Craig, Brett, and Riley provide the hands-on support that makes the charter suitable for both newcomers and regular anglers.
Choose four hours for a manageable introduction, six hours for a balanced fishing day, or eight hours if everyone wants to stay out most of the day. If your group is small, compare the per-person cost carefully. For a full party, the $900 price is easier to defend, especially with the private boat and included equipment.
The best reason to book is control: your group gets the boat, the crew’s attention, and several fishing methods to try. The main caution is simple and honest: weather and fish remain in charge.
FAQ
Where does the fishing charter begin?
The charter begins at The Perry Hotel & Marina, 7001 Shrimp Road, Key West, Florida 33040. The activity ends back at the same meeting point.
How many people can join the private charter?
Up to six passengers can join. The boat is private, so no other groups participate in your trip.
How long is the fishing trip?
The experience is available as a four-hour, six-hour, or eight-hour charter. The listed tour duration is approximately four hours, while the longer options provide more time offshore.
Are fishing gear and licenses included?
Yes. The charter provides the necessary fishing equipment, lures, bait, and fishing license.
What fish might I catch?
Depending on the season and conditions, possible targets include mahi mahi, snapper, grouper, king mackerel, wahoo, tuna, sailfish, and other species.
What happens if the weather is poor?
The experience requires good weather. If it is canceled because of poor conditions, you can select a different date or receive a full refund. You can also cancel at least 24 hours before the start time for a full refund.
More Fishing Charters in Key West
- Half-Day Backcountry Fishing Charter from Key West
★ 5.0 · 13 reviews - Marathon Reef Fishing Charters
★ 5.0 · 7 reviews - Marathon Offshore Fishing Charter
★ 3.0 · 2 reviews - 4-Hour Day or Night-Time Reef Bottom Fishing Charter in Fort Lauderdale
★ 4.5 · 365 reviews
More Private Fishing Charters in Key West
- Key West Private Fishing Charters- 4 HRS 36 FT HATTERAS COWBOY
★ 5.0 · 5 reviews - Private Fishing Trip “All Inclusive” in Cabo San Lucas, Mexico
★ 4.5 · 418 reviews - Private Fishing Charter in Ketchikan
★ 5.0 · 367 reviews - Santorini Fishing Private Cruise boat tour – BBQ, Snorkeling
★ 5.0 · 354 reviews
Just landed around Key West
- Private Fishing Charter Florida Keys★ 5.0 · 6 reviews
- 4 hours Private Fishing Charters in Key West 40 Ft Irish Cowboy★ 5.0 · 9 reviews
- Deep Sea Fishing-Key West Since 1965-45 FT Cowgirl-Cold AC-4 Hrs★ 4.5 · 11 reviews
- Key West Private Fishing Charters- 4 HRS 36 FT HATTERAS COWBOY★ 5.0 · 5 reviews
- Marathon Offshore Fishing Charter★ 3.0 · 2 reviews
- Marathon Reef Fishing Charters★ 5.0 · 7 reviews
- Key West Night Fishing Head Boat Fishing Trip★ 3.5 · 2 reviews
- Key West Sandbar Fishing Snorkel Catch and Cook Excursions★ 5.0 · 9 reviews
Private Fishing Charters in the USA, compared.

Private Sportfishing Charter For Up To 6 People
Read our review →
Private Luxury Sportfishing Experience Aboard Limitless
Read our review →
Private 2 Hour Kids and Family Fishing Marco Island, FL
Read our review →




