Review · KEY WEST

Key West Deep Sea Fishing: Big Fish

★ 5.0 · 112 reviews 4 hours (approx.) From $950 per boat, up to 6 Operated by Corsair 2 Sportfishing · Bookable on Viator
Book on Viator →

The fish are the main event here. Corsair 2 Sportfishing takes your private group as far as 18 miles offshore, where you may hook mahi mahi, wahoo, tuna, sailfish, marlin, snapper, grouper, and other saltwater species. Captain Jeff, Christian, Craig, Brett, and other crew members have helped families and seasoned anglers bring home memorable catches.

I like the private format, since your group of up to six fishes together rather than sharing a boat with strangers. I also like the choice of a short four-hour trip or longer 3/4-day and full-day outings. The main caution is simple: fishing is fishing. One group came home empty-handed, and rough seas made another outing uncomfortable for a seasick passenger.

Key points before you book

Key West Deep Sea Fishing: Big Fish - Key points before you book

  • Up to 18 miles offshore: The trip reaches deep-sea and reef fishing grounds, not just the waters close to Key West.
  • Private boat for up to six: Your party gets the full outing without other bookings aboard.
  • Several trip lengths: Pick a four-hour, 3/4-day, or full-day charter.
  • Big catch potential: Mahi mahi, wahoo, tuna, sailfish, marlin, snapper, and grouper are among the possible targets.
  • Crew involvement matters: Captain Jeff, Christian, Craig, Brett, and other crew members have been praised for working hard and helping with the catch.
  • Weather can change the plan: Poor conditions may lead to a new date or a full refund, but ordinary fishing luck is not guaranteed.

Leaving Key West for open-water fishing

Key West Deep Sea Fishing: Big Fish - Leaving Key West for open-water fishing

You meet at 5950 Peninsular Avenue, Key West, then return to the same point at the end. The boat ride itself is part of the experience, and on a four-hour charter it takes a meaningful share of your time. That matters when you compare the short trip with the longer options.

Once offshore, you can fish in deep water and around reef areas as far as 18 miles from Key West. The setting changes from a quick harbor outing to a proper offshore fishing day, with more time spent reaching productive water and moving between fishing spots.

I would choose a longer trip if catching fish is the main reason you are booking. Four hours gives you a taste of the sport and may be enough for a family with mixed interests. A 3/4-day or full-day outing gives the crew more time to work different areas if the first spot is quiet.

The ride can be rough. One family had a choppy day, and a child became seasick, though the group still caught a barracuda and four mahi mahi. If anyone in your group is sensitive to motion, take that seriously when choosing the length of the trip. Four hours may be easier to manage than a full day, but the ride offshore can still be uncomfortable.

More Deep Sea Fishing Trips in the USA

What you can fish for offshore

The possible catch covers both popular table fish and the sort of powerful species that make a fishing charter memorable. Mahi mahi are a frequent highlight, and several outings produced multiple fish. A large mahi mahi was the personal prize for one angler, while another group caught four.

You may also fish for:

  • Wahoo
  • Tuna
  • Sailfish
  • Marlin
  • Snapper
  • Grouper
  • Barracuda
  • Mackerel

A sailfish was brought in on one especially successful outing. Other groups caught barracuda, mackerel, and several fish for dinner. That range is useful to understand: you are not booking a single-species trip. The crew may adjust the plan according to conditions, the water, and what is biting.

Still, the species list is a menu of possibilities, not a promise. One four-hour outing produced no fish, and another caught only mackerel and small barracuda. That is part of the deal with any fishing charter, even when the price is high. A skilled captain can improve your odds, but cannot control the fish.

Captain and mate make the difference

Key West Deep Sea Fishing: Big Fish - Captain and mate make the difference

The crew is a major part of this experience. Captain Jeff and Christian have been singled out for friendly service and hard work. Craig and Brett have also received strong praise, with Brett handling the mate’s work and Craig taking the captain’s role on some trips. Other outings mention Captain Russ and Captain Rob.

The consistent strength is the crew’s practical help. They put lines in, help when fish are hooked, and work to give each person a chance. First-time anglers can need a lot of direction, especially when a fish changes speed or heads in a different direction. A good mate can turn confusion into a fish in the boat.

The crew has also filleted catches for groups to take home. One family cooked its fish at a local restaurant after the trip, and the captain explained ways to prepare different species. That adds real value if your goal is dinner, not just a photograph.

Expect a working fishing boat, not a polished sightseeing yacht. One angler praised the boat’s condition on one trip, while another described an older boat with visible wear and limited comfortable seating. That difference is worth keeping in mind. The boat may suit people who want to fish more than lounge.

One practical point from a past outing: the crew warned passengers not to bring bananas. Banana superstition is common among fishing crews, though the supplied details do not explain this boat’s exact rule. I would ask when you book rather than arrive with a fruit basket and test maritime tradition.

Four hours, 3/4-day, or full day?

Key West Deep Sea Fishing: Big Fish - Four hours, 3/4-day, or full day?

The four-hour charter is the easiest choice for a first offshore outing, a family with younger participants, or a group that wants to fit fishing around the rest of a Key West visit. It gives you a real trip offshore without committing most of the day.

The tradeoff is time. Part of a four-hour outing is spent getting to and from the fishing grounds. If the fish are slow, the clock moves quickly. One disappointed angler felt the crew watched the time closely and that the ride took too much of the trip.

The 3/4-day option gives you more room to settle in and wait for the bite. It can be a good middle choice for a family that wants a serious fishing session without giving up the entire day. One family used this format on a choppy day and still had a positive outing, including fish filleted for dinner.

The full-day option is best for serious anglers and groups with a shared goal. A full-day family trip included people from age 16 to 77, with everyone catching fish. That is a useful sign that the format can work for mixed ages and skill levels, as long as everyone is comfortable being on the water for many hours.

The longer trips also give the captain more flexibility. If one area is quiet, there is more time to try another. No duration guarantees a catch, but extra time gives you more chances.

More Deep Sea Fishing Trips in Key West:

A private charter for six

Key West Deep Sea Fishing: Big Fish - A private charter for six

The price is $950 per group, for up to six people. At the maximum group size, that works out to about $158 per person. For two people, the per-person cost is much higher, so this charter makes the most financial sense for a full group of family or friends.

Private booking changes the feel of the outing. You can fish with your own party, choose the pace that suits your group, and avoid sharing the boat with unrelated passengers. It is especially useful when one person is experienced, another is trying deep-sea fishing for the first time, and everyone wants to stay together.

The price should be judged against the time and service, not only the fish. You are paying for a private boat, a captain, a mate, access to offshore grounds, and help handling the catch. Bottled water is included, but alcoholic drinks are not.

The value is strongest when your group fills most of the six available places and cares about the whole day on the water. It is harder to justify if you are booking mainly for guaranteed dinner. There is no catch guarantee, and a poor day can leave you feeling the cost sharply.

What happens when you catch a fish

Key West Deep Sea Fishing: Big Fish - What happens when you catch a fish

The most exciting part is not simply feeling a fish bite. It is the work that follows. You need to keep control of the line, follow instructions, and bring the fish close enough for the mate to help land it. The crew’s role is important here, particularly for first-timers.

Past outings included several fish caught in the first couple of hours, multiple lines producing fish at nearly the same time, and catches of mahi mahi, barracuda, sailfish, and other species. Those moments can keep a group busy and make the hours pass quickly.

At the end, the crew may fillet the fish for you to take home. This has been done on several outings, but I would confirm the current arrangement before booking if keeping the catch is central to your plans. You should also plan how you will handle the fish afterward, since the activity details only confirm the return to the meeting point and bottled water.

A successful catch can become part of your evening meal. One group took its fish to a local restaurant and enjoyed a family dinner, while the captain offered preparation advice. That is one of the more authentic rewards of a fishing trip in Key West: you are not only looking at the sea, you may eat a small part of it later.

Boat comfort, seasickness, and fishing style

Key West Deep Sea Fishing: Big Fish - Boat comfort, seasickness, and fishing style

This is an active outing. Seating may be limited or less comfortable for people who are not currently fishing. One passenger specifically wished for better seating, so I would not choose this charter for someone who wants a cushioned cruise with plenty of room to relax.

Boat condition has also received mixed treatment. Some outings describe the boat as being in good shape, while another found it old and worn. That does not necessarily predict your trip, but it is a fair reason to ask the operator which boat and crew are scheduled for your date.

The fishing style may also require you to follow the crew’s instructions closely. One experienced angler disliked being told to leave the rod in the holder and reel from the gunwale rather than lifting it freely. If you have strong ideas about how you want to fish, ask about the boat’s procedures before you pay.

Service animals are allowed, and the activity is near public transportation. Most people can participate, but the combination of open water, boat movement, and limited seating makes physical comfort worth considering. The booking confirmation is provided at the time of reservation, and the ticket is mobile.

Weather and cancellation rules

Key West Deep Sea Fishing: Big Fish - Weather and cancellation rules

The charter requires good weather. If poor weather cancels the trip, you can choose another date or receive a full refund.

The standard cancellation policy is strict: the experience is non-refundable and cannot be changed for any reason. If you cancel or request an amendment, you do not receive your payment back. I would avoid booking until your group is sure about the date.

The weather rule protects you from losing the entire amount when conditions make the trip unsafe or impractical. It does not protect you from a slow fishing day, seasickness, or disappointment with the catch. Those are risks you accept when you book.

Who should book this Key West charter?

I would recommend it most to a group of friends or family members who want a private fishing day and are happy to share the cost. Experienced anglers will appreciate the chance to work offshore grounds for larger species, while first-timers can benefit from the crew’s hands-on help.

It can also work well for a mixed-age family. A full-day outing succeeded with people ranging from 16 to 77, and several families praised the crew for making the trip fun and accessible. The shorter trip may be better for anyone unsure about seasickness or a long day in the sun.

I would hesitate if your priority is comfort, quiet sightseeing, or a guaranteed meal. The boat may feel worn, seating may be limited, and fish are never promised. I would also think twice before choosing the four-hour option if your group wants the best possible chance at a large offshore catch, since travel time uses part of the outing.

Should you book Corsair 2 Sportfishing?

Book this charter if you want a genuine fishing outing rather than a scenic boat ride. The private setup, broad range of possible fish, and hard-working crew give the trip real appeal. At 4.8 out of 5, with 96 percent of customers recommending it, the overall record is strong, though the mixed comments on boat wear, comfort, rough water, and empty-handed days deserve attention.

For the best value, bring five or six people, choose the longest duration your group can comfortably handle, and accept that the sea makes the final decision. If you want a first taste of deep-sea fishing, the four-hour trip is a sensible introduction. If you are chasing a memorable catch, give yourself more time offshore.

FAQ

Where does the fishing charter meet?

The meeting point is 5950 Peninsular Avenue, Key West, Florida 33040. The activity ends back at the same meeting point.

How far offshore does the boat go?

The charter fishes in deep-sea and reef areas up to 18 miles offshore.

How many people can join the private charter?

The price covers one private group of up to six people. Only your group participates.

How long does the fishing trip last?

The listed trip is approximately four hours. Half-day, 3/4-day, and full-day durations are available.

What fish might I catch?

Possible catches include mahi mahi, wahoo, tuna, sailfish, marlin, snapper, grouper, barracuda, mackerel, and other fish.

What happens if bad weather cancels the trip?

If poor weather causes cancellation, you can choose a different date or receive a full refund. The normal cancellation policy is otherwise non-refundable and does not allow changes for any reason.

More like this

Deep Sea Fishing Trips in the USA, compared.

The full Deep Sea Fishing Trips in the USA list →
Half-Day Deep-Sea Fishing at Riviera Beach
★★★★★★★★★★4.5· 366 reviews· from $80

Half-Day Deep-Sea Fishing at Riviera Beach

Read our review →
Fort Lauderdale: 4-Hour Deep Sea Drift Fishing Trip
★★★★★★★★★★4.3· 297 reviews· from $85

Fort Lauderdale: 4-Hour Deep Sea Drift Fishing Trip

Read our review →
Miami Half Day Deep Sea Fishing Trip from Bayside Marketplace
★★★★★★★★★★3.5· 223 reviews· from $80

Miami Half Day Deep Sea Fishing Trip from Bayside Marketplace

Read our review →
Miami Big Game Deep Sea Fishing Charter
★★★★★★★★★★4.5· 198 reviews· $1,000 a boat

Miami Big Game Deep Sea Fishing Charter

Read our review →
Shared BIG GAME Sportfishing Up To Six People
★★★★★★★★★★4.5· 142 reviews· from $250

Shared BIG GAME Sportfishing Up To Six People

Read our review →
Deep Sea Fishing Four Hour Experience with Experienced Captain
★★★★★★★★★★4.5· 61 reviews· from $180

Deep Sea Fishing Four Hour Experience with Experienced Captain

Read our review →
Half Day Offshore Fishing Trip
★★★★★★★★★★4.0· 48 reviews· from $85

Half Day Offshore Fishing Trip

Read our review →
Shared Deep Sea Fishing Trip from Destin
★★★★★★★★★★4.0· 44 reviews· from $169

Shared Deep Sea Fishing Trip from Destin

Read our review →
Scroll to Top

Explore fishing trips

Pick a kind of water, then a coast.